The DRI2 Extension Version 2.0 2008-09-04 Kristian Høgsberg krh@redhat.com Red Hat, Inc 1. Introduction The DRI2 extension is designed to associate and access auxillary rendering buffers with an X drawable. DRI2 is a essentially a helper extension to support implementation of direct rendering drivers/libraries/technologies. The main consumer of this extension will be a direct rendering OpenGL driver, but the DRI2 extension is not designed to be OpenGL specific. Direct rendering implementations of OpenVG, Xv, cairo and other graphics APIs should find the functionality exposed by this extension helpful and hopefully sufficient. Relation to XF86DRI 1.1. Acknowledgements Kevin E. Martin Keith Packard Eric Anholt Keith Whitwell Jerome Glisse Ian Romanick Michel Dänzer Jesse Barnes ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ 2. DRI2 Concepts 2.1. Attachment points Stolen from OpenGL FBOs, I guess. 2.2. Kernel rendering manager This specification assumes a rendering architechture, where an underlying kernel rendering manager that can provide 32 bit integer handles to video memory buffers. These handles can be passed between processes, which, through a direct rendering driver, submit rendering to the kernel rendering manager, targeting and/or sourcing from these buffers. This extension provides a means to communicate about such buffers as associated with an X drawable. The details of how the a direct rendering driver use the buffer names and submit the rendering requests is outside the scope of this specification. However, Appendix B does discuss implementation of this specification on the Graphics Execution Manager (GEM). 2.3. Request ordering No ordering between swap buffers and X rendering. X rendering to src buffers will block if they have a vblank pending. 2.4 Authentication model The purpose of the DRM authentication scheme is to grant access to the kernel rendering manager buffers created by the X server if, and only if, the client has access to the X server. This is achieved in a three-step protocol: 1) The client gets a token from the kernel rendering manager that uniquely identifies it. The token is a 32 bit integer. 2) The client passes the token to the X server in the DRI2Authenticate request. This request is a round trip to make sure the X server has received and processed the authentication before the client starts accessing the DRM. 3) The X server authorizes the client by passing the token to the kernel rendering manager. A kernel rendering manager can choose not to implement any authentication and just allow access to all buffers. 2.5 Rendering to the X front buffer OpenGL allows the client to render to the front buffer, either by using a single-buffered configuration or but explicitly setting the draw buffer to GL_FRONT_LEFT. Not allowed! The client must ask for a fake front buffer, render to that and then use DRI2CopyRegion to copy contents back and forth between the fake front buffer and the real front buffer. When X and direct rendering to a front buffer is interleaved, it is the responsibility of the application to synchronize access using glXWaitGL and glXWaitX. A DRI2 implementation of direct rendering GLX, should use these enty points to copy contents back and forth to as necessary to ensure consistent rendering. The client may also use the DRI2SwapBuffers function to request a swap of the front and back buffers. If the display server supports it, this operation may be preferred, since it may be easier and/or more performant for the server to perform a simple buffer swap rather than a blit. 2.6 Synchronizing rendering DRI2 provides several methods for synchronizing drawing with various events. The protocol for these methods is based on the SGI_video_sync and OML_sync_control GLX extensions. Using the DRI2WaitMSC request, a client can wait for a specific frame count or divisor/remainder before continuing its processing. With the DRI2WaitSBC request, clients can block until a given swap count is reached (as incremented by DRI2SwapBuffers). Finally, using DRI2SwapBuffers, clients can limit their frame rate by specifying a swap interval using the swap interval call (currently only available through GLX) or by using the OML swap buffers routine. 2.7 Events DRI2 provides an event to indicate when a DRI2SwapBuffers request has been completed. This can be used to throttle drawing on the client side and tie into application main loops. Another event is generated when the validity of the requested buffers changes. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ 3. Data Types The server side region support specified in the Xfixes extension version 2 is used in the CopyRegion request. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ 4. Errors No errors are defined by the DRI2 extension. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ 5. Events The only events provided by DRI2 are DRI2_BufferSwapComplete and DRI2InvalidateBuffers. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ 6. Protocol Types DRI2DRIVER { DRI2DriverDRI DRI2DriverVDPAU, DRI2DriverXV } These values describe the type of driver the client will want to load. The server sends back the name of the driver to use for the screen in question. DRI2ATTACHMENT { DRI2BufferFrontLeft DRI2BufferBackLeft DRI2BufferFrontRight DRI2BufferBackRight DRI2BufferDepth DRI2BufferStencil DRI2BufferAccum DRI2BufferFakeFrontLeft DRI2BufferFakeFrontRight DRI2BufferDepthStencil DRI2BufferHiz } These values describe various attachment points for DRI2 buffers. In the case of video driver (DRI2DriverXV) the attachment, other than DRI2BufferFrontLeft, just indicates buffer number and has no other special significance. There is no automatic maintenance of DRI2BufferFakeFrontLeft. DRI2BUFFER { attachment: CARD32 name: CARD32 pitch: CARD32 cpp: CARD32 flags: CARD32 } The DRI2BUFFER describes an auxillary rendering buffer associated with an X drawable. 'attachment' describes the attachment point for the buffer, 'name' is the name of the underlying kernel buffer. DRI2ATTACH_FORMAT { attachment: CARD32 format: CARD32 } The DRI2ATTACH_FORMAT describes an attachment and the associated format. 'attachment' describes the attachment point for the buffer, 'format' describes an opaque, device-dependent format for the buffer, or a fourcc for non-device-dependent formats. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ 7. Extension Initialization The name of this extension is "DRI2". ┌─── DRI2QueryVersion client-major-version: CARD32 client-minor-version: CARD32 ▶ major-version: CARD32 minor-version: CARD32 └─── The client sends the highest supported version to the server and the server sends the highest version it supports, but no higher than the requested version. Major versions changes can introduce incompatibilities in existing functionality, minor version changes introduce only backward compatible changes. It is the clients responsibility to ensure that the server supports a version which is compatible with its expectations. Backwards compatible changes included addition of new requests, but also new value types in the DRI2CopyRegion request. When new values are introduced, the minor version will be increased so the client can know which values the X server understands from the version number. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ 8. Extension Requests ┌─── DRI2Connect window: WINDOW driverType: DRI2DRIVER ▶ driver: STRING device: STRING └─── Returns the driver name and device file to use for the specified driver type for the screen associated with 'window'. 'type' identifies the type of driver to query for. 'driver' is the name of the driver to load. The client is assumed to know where to look for the drivers and what to do with it. 'device' is the filename of the DRM device file. If the client is not local, or the request driver type is unknown or not available, 'driver' and 'device' will be empty strings. We are not using an regular X error here to indicate failure, which will allow the client fall back to other options more easily. ISSUE: We could add the list of supported attachments and the supported DRI2CopyRegion values here (just the bitmask of all supported values). ┌─── DRI2Authenticate window: WINDOW token: CARD32 ▶ authenticated: CARD32 └─── Errors: Window Request that the X server authenticates 'token', allowing the client to access the DRM buffers created by the X server on the screen associated with 'window'. Authentication shouldn't fail at this point, except if an invalid token is passed, in which case authenticated is False. ┌─── DRI2GetBuffers drawable: DRAWABLE attachments: LISTofDRI2ATTACHMENTS ▶ width, height: CARD32 buffers: LISTofDRI2BUFFER └─── Errors: Window Get buffers for the provided attachment points for the given drawable. If the DDX driver does not support one or more of the specified attachment points, a Value error is generated, with the first unsupported attachment point as the error value. 'width' and 'height' describes the dimensions of the drawable. 'buffers' is a list of DRI2BUFFER for the given DRI2 attachment points. ┌─── DRI2CopyRegion drawable: DRAWABLE region: REGION source: DRI2ATTACHMENT destination: DRI2ATTACHMENT ▶ └─── Errors: Window, Value Schedule a copy from one DRI2 buffer to another. The DRICopyRegion request has a reply but it is empty. The reply is there to let the direct rendering client wait until the server has seen the request before proceeding with rendering the next frame. ┌─── DRI2SwapBuffers drawable: DRAWABLE target_msc: two CARD32s divisor: two CARD32s remainder: two CARD32s ▶ count: two CARD32s └─── Errors: Window Schedule a swap of the front and back buffers with the display server. Returns the swap count value when the swap will actually occur (e.g. the last queued swap count + (pending swap count * swap interval)). This request is only available with protocol version 1.2 or later. ┌─── DRI2SwapBuffersVid drawable: DRAWABLE target_msc: two CARD32s divisor: two CARD32s remainder: two CARD32s source: CARD32 x1: CARD32 y1: CARD32 x2: CARD32 y2: CARD32 ▶ count: two CARD32s └─── Errors: Window Schedule a swap of the front and back buffers with the display server. Returns the swap count value when the swap will actually occur (e.g. the last queued swap count + (pending swap count * swap interval)). This request is only available with protocol version 1.4 or later. ┌─── DRI2GetBuffersWithFormat drawable: DRAWABLE attachments: LISTofDRI2ATTACH_FORMAT ▶ width, height: CARD32 buffers: LISTofDRI2BUFFER └─── Errors: Window Get buffers for the provided attachment points with the specified formats for the given drawable. If the DDX driver does not support one or more of the specified attachment points or formats, a Value error is generated, with the first unsupported attachment point as the error value. 'width' and 'height' describes the dimensions of the drawable. 'buffers' is a list of DRI2BUFFER for the given DRI2 attachment points. This request is only available with protocol version 1.1 or later. ┌─── DRI2GetBuffersVid drawable: DRAWABLE width, height: CARD32 attachments: LISTofDRI2ATTACH_FORMAT ▶ width, height: CARD32 buffers: LISTofDRI2BUFFER └─── Errors: Window Get buffers for the provided attachment points with the specified formats for the given drawable. Like DRI2GetBuffersWithFormat, but allows the client to specify a buffer size that differs from the target drawable, for example to deal with decoded video which is scaled as it is blit to the front buffer (or rendered via hw overlay). The DRI2BufferFrontLeft attachment point cannot be requested. But for video buffers, the client can dynamically allocate more buffers by just requesting new attachment point id's. Or release a buffer by requesting it with 0,0 size. If the same attachment point is re-requested, then the previous buffer is deallocated and a new buffer is allocated. This allows for dynamic resolution changes during playback. This request is only available with protocol version 1.4 or later. : Note: originally I was not going to add a new DRI2GetBuffers variant, : but instead use attributes to communicate width/height. But the : problem is that the client blindly picks up DRI2_MINOR from dri2proto.h : and so there is otherwise no reliable way for the server to know if : client supports extra_buffers.. ┌─── DRI2GetMSC drawable: DRAWABLE ▶ ust, msc, sbc: CARD64 └─── Errors: Window Get the current media stamp counter (MSC) and swap buffer count (SBC) along with the unadjusted system time (UST) when the MSC was last incremented. This request is only available with protocol version 1.2 or later. ┌─── DRI2WaitMSC drawable: DRAWABLE target_msc: two CARD32s divisor: two CARD32s remainder: two CARD32s ▶ ust, msc, sbc: CARD64 └─── Errors: Window Blocks the client until either the frame count reaches target_msc or, if the frame count is already greater than target_msc when the request is received, until the frame count % divisor = remainder. If divisor is 0, the client will be unblocked if the frame count is greater than or equal to the target_msc. Returns the current media stamp counter (MSC) and swap buffer count (SBC) along with the unadjusted system time (UST) when the MSC was last incremented. This request is only available with protocol version 1.2 or later. ┌─── DRI2WaitSBC drawable: DRAWABLE target_sbc: two CARD32s ▶ ust, msc, sbc: CARD64 └─── Errors: Window Blocks the client until the swap buffer count reaches target_sbc. If the swap buffer count is already greater than or equal to target_sbc when the request is recieved, this request will return immediately. If target_sbc is 0, this request will block the client until all previous DRI2SwapBuffers requests have completed. Returns the current media stamp counter (MSC) and swap buffer count (SBC) along with the unadjusted system time (UST) when the MSC was last incremented. This request is only available with protocol version 1.2 or later. ┌─── DRI2SwapInterval drawable: DRAWABLE interval: CARD32 ▶ └─── Errors: Window Sets the swap interval for DRAWABLE. This will throttle DRI2SwapBuffers requests to swap at most once per interval frames, which is useful useful for limiting the frame rate. ┌─── DRI2GetParam drawable: DRAWABLE param: CARD32 ▶ is_param_recognized: BOOL value: CARD64 └─── Errors: Drawable Get the value of a parameter. The parameter's value is looked up on the screen associated with 'drawable'. Parameter names in which the value of the most significant byte is 0 are reserved for the X server. Currently, no such parameter names are defined. (When any such names are defined, they will be defined in this extension specification and its associated headers). Parameter names in which the byte's value is 1 are reserved for the DDX. Such names are private to each driver and shall be defined in the respective driver's headers. Parameter names in which the byte's value is neither 0 nor 1 are reserved for future use. Possible values of 'is_param_recognized' are true (1) and false (0). If false, then 'value' is undefined. This request is only available with protocol version 1.4 or later. ┌─── DRI2SetAttribute drawable: DRAWABLE attribute: ATOM value: LISTofCARD32 ▶ └─── Errors: Window, Match, Value The DRI2SetAttribute request sets the value of a drawable attribute. The drawable attribute is identified by the attribute atom. The following strings are guaranteed to generate valid atoms using the InternAtom request. String Size Type ----------------------------------------------------------------- "XV_CSC_MATRIX" 48 4x3 matrix of floats "XV_OSD" 4 XID If the given attribute doesn't match an attribute supported by the drawable a Match error is generated. The supplied encoding must be one of the encodings listed for the adaptor, otherwise an Encoding error is generated. The XV_CSC_MATRIX attribute is defined to match the VDPAU VdpCSCMatrix: ┌ ┐ ┌ ┐ ┌ ┐ │ R │ │ m00 m01 m02 m03 │ │ Y │ │ G │ = │ m10 m11 m12 m13 │ * │ Cb │ │ B │ │ m20 m21 m22 m23 │ │ Cr │ └ ┘ └ ┘ │ 1.0 │ └ ┘ If the adaptor doesn't support the specified CSC matrix, the closest values supported are assumed. The DRI2GetAttribute request can be used to query the resulting values. The "XV_OSD" attribute specifies the XID of a drawable containing ARGB data to be non-destructively overlayed over the video. This could be used to implement subtiles, on-screen-menus, etc. Note that a DRI2DriverDRI driver could be connected to this drawable, to enable GPU rendered OSD content, or alternatively normal indirect X11 draw primitives can be used. This request is only available with protocol version 1.4 or later. ┌─── DRI2GetAttribute drawable: DRAWABLE attribute: ATOM ▶ value: LISTofCARD32 └─── Errors: Window, Match The DRI2GetAttribute request returns the current value of the attribute identified by the given atom. If the given atom doesn't match an attribute supported by the adaptor a Match error is generated. This request is only available with protocol version 1.4 or later. ┌─── DRI2GetFormats drawable: DRAWABLE ▶ formats: LISTofCARD32 └─── Errors: Window Query the driver for supported formats, which can be used with DRI2GetBuffersWithFormat. The 'format' describes an opaque, device-dependent format for the buffer, or a fourcc for non-device-dependent formats. For device-dependent formats, use at least one '\0' or non 7-bit ascii character. This request is only available with protocol version 1.4 or later. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ 9. Extension Events ┌─── DRI2BufferSwapComplete ▶ event_type: CARD16 drawable: CARD32 ust: CARD64 msc: CARD64 sbc: CARD64 └─── This event reports the status of the last DRI2SwapBuffers event to the client. The event type should be one of DRI2_EXCHANGE_COMPLETE, indicating a successful buffer exchange, DRI2_BLIT_COMPLETE, indicating the swap was performed with a blit, and DRI2_FLIP_COMPLETE, indicating a full page flip was completed. ┌─── DRI2InvalidateBuffers ▶ drawable: CARD32 └─── This event is generated when the buffers the client had requested for 'drawable' (with DRI2GetBuffers or DRI2GetBuffersWithFormat) become inappropriate because they don't match the drawable dimensions anymore, or a buffer swap has been performed. Note that the server is only required to warn the client once about this condition, until the client takes care of bringing them back up-to-date with another GetBuffers request. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ 10. Extension Versioning The DRI2 extension has undergone a number of revisions before 1.0: Released, but never used. Relied on a number of constructs from the XF86DRI extension, such as a shared memory area (SAREA) to communicate changes in cliprects and window sizes, and 1.99.1: Move the swap buffer functionality into the X server, introduce SwapBuffer request to copy back buffer contents to the X drawable. 1.99.2: Rethink the SwapBuffer request as an asynchronous request to copy a region between DRI2 buffers. Drop CreateDrawable and DestroyDrawable, update Connect to support different driver types and to send the authentication group. 1.99.3: Drop the bitmask argument intended to indicate presence of optional arguments for CopyRegion. 2.0: Awesomeness! 2.1: True excellence. Added DRI2GetBuffersWithFormat to allow more flexible object creation. 2.2: Approaching perfection. Added requests for swapbuffers, MSC and SBC related requests, and events. 2.3: Added the DRI2InvalidateBuffers event. 2.6: Enlightenment attained. Added the DRI2BufferHiz attachment. 2.7: Added the DRI2GetParam request. Compatibility up to 2.0 is not preserved, but was also never released. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ 11. Relationship with other extensions As an extension designed to support other extensions, there is naturally some interactions with other extensions. 11.1 GLX The GL auxilary buffers map directly to the DRI2 buffers... eh 11.2 DBE The DBE back buffer must correspond to the DRI2_BUFFER_FRONT_LEFT DRI2 buffer for servers that support both DBE and DRI2. 11.3 XvMC / Xv We might add a DRI2_BUFFER_YUV to do vsynced colorspace conversion blits. Maybe... not really sure. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ Appendix A. Protocol Encoding Syntactic Conventions This document uses the same syntactic conventions as the core X protocol encoding document. A.1 Common Types ┌─── DRI2DRIVER 0x0 DRI2DriverDRI 0x1 DRI2DriverVDPAU └─── ┌─── DRI2ATTACHMENT 0x0 DRI2BufferFrontLeft 0x1 DRI2BufferBackLeft 0x2 DRI2BufferFrontRight 0x3 DRI2BufferBackRight 0x4 DRI2BufferDepth 0x5 DRI2BufferStencil 0x6 DRI2BufferAccum 0x7 DRI2BufferFakeFrontLeft 0x8 DRI2BufferFakeFrontRight 0x9 DRI2BufferDepthStencil 0xa DRI2BufferHiz └─── Used to encode the possible attachment points. The attachment DRI2BufferDepthStencil is only available with protocol version 1.1 or later. ┌─── DRI2BUFFER (in response to DRI2GetBuffers & DRI2GetBuffersWithFormat) 4 CARD32 attachment 4 CARD32 name 4 CARD32 pitch 4 CARD32 cpp 4 CARD32 flags └─── A DRI2 buffer specifies the attachment, the kernel memory manager name, the pitch and chars per pixel for a buffer attached to a given drawable. ┌─── DRI2BUFFER (in response to DRI2GetBuffersVid) 4 CARD32 attachment 4 CARD32 name 4 CARD32 pitch 4 CARD32 cpp 4 CARD32 flags 4 n extra names length 8n LISTof extra name, pitch └─── A DRI2 buffer specifies the attachment, the kernel memory manager name and the pitch for a buffer attached to a given drawable. Note that cpp is unused (it is a bit difficult to represent values like 1.5 bytes/pixel as an integer). In case of multi-planar video formats, 'extra names' will give the list of additional buffer names (and their pitch) if there is one buffer per plane. For example, I420 has one Y plane in with a 8bit luma value per pixel, followed by one U plane subsampled 2x2 (with one 8bit U value per 2x2 pixel block), followed by one V plane subsampled 2x2. This could either be represented as a single buffer name, or three separate buffer names, one each for Y, U, and V. ┌─── DRI2ATTACH_FORMAT 4 CARD32 attachment 4 CARD32 format └─── Used to describe the attachment and format requested from the server. This data type is only available with protocol version 1.1 or later. A.2 Protocol Requests ┌─── DRI2QueryVersion 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 0 DRI2 opcode 2 3 length 4 CARD32 major version 4 CARD32 minor version ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 major version 4 CARD32 minor version 16 unused └─── ┌─── DRI2Connect 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 1 DRI2 opcode 2 3 length 4 WINDOW window 4 CARD32 driver type ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 (n+m+p+q)/4 reply length 4 n driver name length 4 m device name length 16 unused n CARD8 driver name p unused, p=pad(n) m CARD8 device name q unused, q=pad(m) └─── ┌─── DRI2Authenticate 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 2 DRI2 opcode 2 3 length 4 WINDOW window 4 CARD32 authentication token ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 authenticated 20 unused └─── ┌─── DRI2GetBuffers 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 5 DRI2 opcode 2 3 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 n number of attachments 4n LISTofDRI2ATTACHMENTS attachments ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 width of drawable 4 CARD32 height of drawable 4 CARD32 buffer count 12 unused 5n LISTofDRI2BUFFER buffers └─── ┌─── DRI2CopyRegion 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 6 DRI2 opcode 2 3 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 REGION region 4 DRI2ATTACHMENT source 4 DRI2ATTACHMENT destination ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 24 unused └─── ┌─── DRI2GetBuffersWithFormat 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 7 DRI2 opcode 2 3 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 n number of attachments 8n LISTofDRI2ATTACH_FORMAT attachments and formats ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 width of drawable 4 CARD32 height of drawable 4 CARD32 buffer count 12 unused 5n LISTofDRI2BUFFER buffers └─── ┌─── DRI2GetBuffersVid 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 3 DRI2 opcode 2 3 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 CARD32 width 4 CARD32 height 4 n number of attachments 4n LISTofDRI2ATTACHMENTS attachments ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 width of drawable 4 CARD32 height of drawable 4 CARD32 buffer count 12 unused 5n LISTofDRI2BUFFER buffers └─── ┌─── DRI2SwapBuffers 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 8 DRI2 opcode 2 8 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 CARD32 target_msc_hi 4 CARD32 target_msc_lo 4 CARD32 divisor_hi 4 CARD32 divisor_lo 4 CARD32 remainder_hi 4 CARD32 remainder_lo ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 swap_hi 4 CARD32 swap_lo 5n LISTofDRI2BUFFER buffers └─── ┌─── DRI2SwapBuffersVid 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 8 DRI2 opcode 2 8 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 CARD32 target_msc_hi 4 CARD32 target_msc_lo 4 CARD32 divisor_hi 4 CARD32 divisor_lo 4 CARD32 remainder_hi 4 CARD32 remainder_lo 4 DRI2ATTACHMENT source 4 CARD32 x1 4 CARD32 y1 4 CARD32 x2 4 CARD32 y2 ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 swap_hi 4 CARD32 swap_lo 5n LISTofDRI2BUFFER buffers └─── ┌─── DRI2GetMSC 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 9 DRI2 opcode 2 8 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 ust_hi 4 CARD32 ust_lo 4 CARD32 msc_hi 4 CARD32 msc_lo 4 CARD32 sbc_hi 4 CARD32 sbc_lo └─── ┌─── DRI2WaitMSC 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 10 DRI2 opcode 2 8 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 CARD32 target_msc_hi 4 CARD32 target_msc_lo 4 CARD32 divisor_hi 4 CARD32 divisor_lo 4 CARD32 remainder_hi 4 CARD32 remainder_lo ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 ust_hi 4 CARD32 ust_lo 4 CARD32 msc_hi 4 CARD32 msc_lo 4 CARD32 sbc_hi 4 CARD32 sbc_lo └─── ┌─── DRI2WaitSBC 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 11 DRI2 opcode 2 8 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 CARD32 swap_hi 4 CARD32 swap_lo ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 ust_hi 4 CARD32 ust_lo 4 CARD32 msc_hi 4 CARD32 msc_lo 4 CARD32 sbc_hi 4 CARD32 sbc_lo └─── ┌─── DRI2SwapInterval 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 12 DRI2 opcode 2 8 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 CARD32 interval ▶ └─── ┌─── DRI2GetParam 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 13 DRI2 opcode 2 8 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 CARD32 param ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 BOOL is_param_recognized 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 4 CARD32 value_hi 4 CARD32 value_lo 16 unused └─── ┌─── DRI2SetAttribute 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 7 DRI2 opcode 2 8 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 ATOM attribute 4n LISTofCARD32 value ▶ └─── ┌─── DRI2GetAttribute 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 7 DRI2 opcode 2 8 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 ATOM attribute ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 24 unused 4n LISTofCARD32 value └─── ┌─── DRI2GetFormats 1 CARD8 major opcode 1 7 DRI2 opcode 2 8 length 4 DRAWABLE drawable ▶ 1 1 Reply 1 unused 2 CARD16 sequence number 4 0 reply length 24 unused 4n LISTofCARD32 formats └─── A.3 Protocol Events The DRI2 extension specifies DRI2_BufferSwapComplete and DRI2_InvalidateBuffers events. ┌─── DRI2_BufferSwapComplete 1 CARD8 type 1 CARD8 extension 2 CARD16 sequenceNumber 2 CARD16 event_type 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 CARD32 ust_hi 4 CARD32 ust_lo 4 CARD32 msc_hi 4 CARD32 msc_lo 4 CARD32 sbc_hi 4 CARD32 sbc_lo └─── ┌─── DRI2_InvalidateBuffers 1 CARD8 type 1 CARD8 extension 2 CARD16 sequenceNumber 4 DRAWABLE drawable 4 CARD32 unused 4 CARD32 unused 4 CARD32 unused 4 CARD32 unused 4 CARD32 unused 4 CARD32 unused └─── A.4 Protocol Errors The DRI2 extension specifies no errors. ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ ⚙ Appendix B. Implementation on GEM Where to begin...